Is it time to switch to Windows for video editing? Philip Bloom thinks so - DIY Photography
As a die-hard Apple user for 15 years, Philip was pleased with how well everything seamlessly transitioned over to the Microsoft OS. All his Adobe software settings were stored in the Creative Cloud, so when he installed Premiere and everything else onto Windows, it worked as it had always done on his Mac. Only faster. WAY faster. The actual editing process itself was even faster and smoother.
He can scrub through unrendered files with effects applied whereas his Mac Pro would simply choke. Although MSI did supply the hardware to Philip, too, his points are still quite valid. The primary ones being the speed of the system today given the cost vs the competition, and the potential for future upgrades.
If it starts slowing down, he can whip the side off the case, add in some more RAM, go to a faster graphics card or multiple graphics cards , a new CPU, or add any piece of performance-enhancing hardware he chooses. Trying something new that can give me a big chunk of my life back. He stresses that he is in no way leaving Apple Macs, though.
Is it time to switch to Windows for video editing? Philip Bloom thinks so
He loves how they work, but the speed advantages of a purpose-built PC are undeniable, especially considering the cost. So, if you love your Mac, but want better rendering performance, you may be best going dual system. I know quite a few who edit on a Mac but still use a PC for the rendering grunt work. Even for those on Windows, many just use two PCs; One to edit with and one to render.
Have you made the switch to Windows?
Have you gone the other way and switched to Mac? Do you run both? You can find out more about John on his website and follow his adventures on YouTube and Facebook. I highly recommend the Dell XPS 15! On paper, the Dell XPS line looks great, and it regularly receives top reviews based on a few days of testing.
But in the real world, many people have complained about quality issues. Also, depending on your unit, you may face constant whining. I have a custom built desktop that is my main workhorse. The Air is designed for minimal tasks.
Time to make the switch from Mac to PC for Premiere Pro editing?
If you wanted a better machine you should have bought one to start with. How does the kool aid taste? I was also initially not thrilled by the removal of the USB-A, but after having used a MacBook Pro for about 1 year, the dongle point is really minor. It is just adding a small cable or tiny adapter, which cost a little. In other words, it is not really warranted and objective to not use a MacBook Pro for this reason.
I say it every time a mac vs. You cannot beat the MacOS operating system although there are some things about Windows that I like better , and you cannot beat the capacity for upgrading a custom PC or even some bought from the major manufacturers. And to answer the question posed at the end of the article, I switched from Mac to Windows in My experience has been nowhere near as rocky as Windows XP, which was my last experience with Windows before the switch.
Macbook pro for mobile work, Imac pro for smaller businesses, pc if you need to run a massive production house with multiple editors and want to save money. The same is true for many audio apps. Also I was able to purchase a new battery and change it with my bare hands. Can you do that. So for me it is not a hard decision. Also iOS is just different, not so much better than Windows.
Please do not come up with crashing Win 98… That would be ridiculous. Gee, my HP is still working fine and it was purchased in … i7, 32g, gb ssd c drive and 12 TB storage…I bought my mom a Mac to surf! With the limited availability with Macs, to upgrade, a lifetime is useless.
Technology is ever evolving. We get you love Apple… but attacking others does nothing to validate your loyalty. You too are welcome to use your choice! Dual system is def my preferred setup now. Its the only way to go for video editing. However it must be built right. I use both daily but have preferred Windows ever since XP. There are two reasons. First, you can get a more powerful machine for less money by building your own if you go Windows. Second, Windows computers are easier to troubleshoot.
Well, actually Macs are easier to troubleshoot for minor problems. But if you ever run into a serious problem, Macs can often be impossible to fix, whereas a Windows machine will likely just be very difficult. Jump to. Sections of this page. Accessibility help. Email or Phone Password Forgotten account?
Sign Up. See more of Philip Bloom on Facebook. Log In. Forgotten account? Not Now. Related Pages.
American Cinematographer Arts and entertainment. Filmmaker Magazine.
Philip Bloom Switches to a PC for Editing in 4K
By Kevin P. Now, we are on version In the meantime, Apple did something unprecedented […]. I use them still all the time. My god! That was painful to watch.
Premier is always a render heavy editing suite. It so made me never to want to go to PC or premier ever again. As a feature editor, using Premeiere now. The whole ProRes issue is what would throw me. It seems like the speed is great, but the ending still adds time.
I would like to see how the new iMAC Pro performs since they are shipping shortly. The 5k screens built into the new macs would be ideal for a 4K edit. Now that Apple has put together a pro machine I will stay with them. Philip, I was going the same route and staying with Mac for portable reasons. DnxHD is the actual progress equivalent. News Ticker.